Founded in 2019 by Samuel neagley, Blue Otter Theatre is an independent theatre company based in New York City. We produce bold, original comedy with the goal of uplifting new voices in the performing arts.
We are currently preparing for a robust 2023 season.
"Not Paul" Company Bow (2022)
Brittney Malik and Rick Ames in "All That Glitters Is Sold!" (2021)
Caroline Dunaway, Aakash Jagdale, and Rashaun Fraser in "Not Paul" (2022)
Clayton Smith and Samuel Neagley in "All That Glitters Is Sold!" (2021)
The Cult of Paul , "Not Paul" (2022)
Lucien Formicella in "All That Glitters Is Sold!" (2021)
Gideon Parker in "All That Glitters Is Sold!" (2021)
Brittney Malik in "All That Glitters Is Sold!" (2021)
Josephine Pizzino and Caroline Dunaway in "Not Paul" (2022)